3940 Shelbyville Rd · St. Matthews, LouisvilleTue–Fri 7–5 · Sat 6:30–5502.896.4438GalleryQuestions
Plehn’s BakerySt. Matthews · since 1924 Order from the caseOrder online
Five-tier stand of iced cupcakes at an outdoor party

Menu 02 — Cakes & cupcakes

More cake designs than you can imagine.

Birthdays, showers, first communions and tiers — pick a flavor, a filling and an icing, and our decorators do the rest.

Occasions

A cake for the day you’re planning.

Decorated and custom cakes are ordered by phone or at the counter — they book up, so order early. A plain cake with a message can go in an online order.

  • Birthday cakes
  • Everyday cakes
  • Custom & shapedCall
  • Children’s birthdaysCall
  • Baby showerCall
  • Baptism & First CommunionCall
  • First birthdayCall
  • Tier cakesCall
  • CupcakesBy the dozen
White cake with purple buttercream water lilies and a piped border

Water lilies in buttercream

Build your cake

Flavors, fillings, icings.

Italian Cream isn’t available as cupcakes.

11 flavors

  • Yellow
  • Devilsfood
  • Marble
  • Almond
  • Lemon
  • Orange
  • Strawberry
  • Red Velvet
  • Carrot
  • Spice
  • Italian Cream

7 fillings

  • Raspberry
  • Lemon
  • Lemon Buttercream
  • Orange Buttercream
  • Strawberry Buttercream
  • Caramel Icing
  • Cream Cheese Icing

8 icings

  • Buttercream
  • Cream Cheese
  • Whipped
  • Chocolate
  • Strawberry Buttercream
  • Lemon Buttercream
  • Orange Buttercream
  • Colored Buttercream
Two-tier white cake with red buttercream roses
Red roses, in buttercream.
Tier cakes · call to order

Cupcakes

In the case, or by the dozen.

Seasonal and basic iced cupcakes are in the case with no pre-order. All other cupcakes must be ordered.

FlavorMinimum
Yellow, DevilsfoodNo minimum
Strawberry, Almond, Lemon, Orange1 dozen
Red Velvet, Carrot, Spice3 dozen
Cupcakes piped with buttercream roses and tulips

Next step

Tell us about the cake.

Call with the date, the size and the design you have in mind.

Online = anything from the case, plus a message on a cake. Anything decorated or custom: call or come in.