3940 Shelbyville Rd · St. Matthews, LouisvilleTue–Fri 7–5 · Sat 6:30–5502.896.4438GalleryQuestions
Plehn’s BakerySt. Matthews · since 1924 Order from the caseOrder online
Deli sandwich tray on butter buns
Cloverleaf rolls
Butterfluff rolls

Menu 05 — Deli & ice cream

Benedictine at the deli. Ice cream from the back.

Sliced meats and cheeses, homemade soups and spreads daily — and ice cream we’ve made on site since 1927.

The deli counter

Spreads made in-house.

Fresh sliced meats and cheeses, homemade soups, spreads and salads in our deli every day.

Spreads & salads

  • BenedictineMade here
  • Chicken saladMade here
  • Pimento cheeseMade here
  • Ham saladMade here
  • Country ham saladMade here
  • Egg saladMade here

Meats & cheeses

  • Brown Sugar HamBoar’s Head
  • Turkey BreastBoar’s Head
  • Country Ham
  • Colby Jack · Pepper JackBoar’s Head
  • Cheddar · Swiss · GoudaBoar’s Head
  • AmericanBoar’s Head

Homemade soups

  • Chili
  • Beef Barley
  • Vegetable
  • Chicken Noodle
  • Bean
Deli sandwich tray on butter buns

Sandwich tray on butter buns

Trays

Sandwich and meat-and-cheese trays.

Pick your bread: butter buns (small or large), medium white buns or hamburger buns. Call to order.

Call to order a tray

Ice cream — made here since 1927

Scooped where it’s churned.

Ice cream cakes are round only and need at least 48 hours to set. Call to order one.

  • Vanilla
  • Chocolate
  • Caramel
  • Strawberry
  • Raspberry Chocolate Chip
  • Mint Chocolate Chip
  • Cookies and Cream
  • Peppermint
  • PeachSeasonal

Next step

Lunch for the office?

Call to order a tray, or stop by the deli counter.

Online = anything from the case, plus a message on a cake. Anything decorated or custom: call or come in.