3940 Shelbyville Rd · St. Matthews, LouisvilleTue–Fri 7–5 · Sat 6:30–5502.896.4438GalleryQuestions
Plehn’s BakerySt. Matthews · since 1924 Order from the caseOrder online
Three-tier white wedding cake with orange and teal string work on the bench
String work, three tiers
Two-tier white cake with red buttercream roses on the bench
Red roses
Ivory four-tier wedding cake on a gold stand before a candlelit mantel
At the reception
Two-tier cake with blue sugar flowers on the bench
Blue sugar flowers
White cake with purple buttercream water lilies
Water lilies
Heart-shaped leopard-print birthday cake
Leopard heart
Cake shaped like an ice cream cone with pink icing and sprinkles
Ice cream cone cake
Pink Easter cake topped with piped buttercream carrots
Easter carrots
Two green football-shaped iced cookies lettered X and T
Game-day cookies
Iced Derby horse-head cookie on a plate of pecan cookies
The Derby horse head
Four white-glazed Easter cookies with pink piping, green ruffle icing and icing roses on a pressed-glass plate
Easter iced cookies
Red and green iced Christmas-tree cookies
Iced trees
Five-tier stand of iced cupcakes at an outdoor party
Cupcake tower
Ivory three-tier wedding cake with pearl beading and sugar flowers
Pearls & sugar flowers
Three-tier white textured wedding cake with pale pink roses
Textured tiers
Scrolled buttercream wedding cake with pink and ivory roses
Scrollwork & roses
Tall pillared wedding cake at a candlelit reception
Pillars by candlelight
Two-tier white wedding cake with red buttercream roses
Roses, two tiers

Decorated cakes

Ordered by phone or at the counter. They book up, so order early. Flavors, fillings and icings

Wedding cakes

Every one starts with a free consultation, Tuesday through Saturday, 9am to 3pm. Weddings

Iced cookies

One seasonal iced cookie is in the case every day. Custom cookies are made to order. Cookies

Next step

Seen one you like?

Call with the date, the size and the design you have in mind.

Online = anything from the case, plus a message on a cake. Anything decorated or custom: call or come in.